
Let me start with this about the past couple of weeks- I was in a permanent bad mood. Nothing majorly bad happened, it started on Tuesday 7th February when I was awoken at 5am and put in an instant bad mood. It went downhill from there and it lasted for days. I snapped at anything that rubbed me the wrong way. How I kept my temper when I saw what I'm about to tell you all is beyond me. I just knew that I had to leave it for the moment and decide on what to do with this information when I was in a better mood...which is now, two weeks on.
So here it is...
On the 7th February I had a short but very insightful Twitter conversation with an author. It all started with a tweet of his stating:
Just realised something rather comforting. The negative Amazon reviews of my book have all been written by idiots.

Yes, that's right people. You did read that correctly.
Anyway, I sat there staring at my screen in mild disbelief. After everything that has been happening in the book review/blogger world, someone would still come out with this in a public forum. Having learnt from past experience of authors going on a rant before deleting, I screen capped the tweet. Then I checked his Twitter profile and low and behold- the tweet had disappeared just a few minutes after he'd put it.
I couldn't leave it. It was too late. I'd seen his reaction to negative reviews already and it was stuck with me.
Now, let me say this- I hate confrontation of any kind. I start shaking at the thought of it, my heart races, and then the Waterworks of Anger quickly arrive. However, if I feel something is wrong, I can't keep quiet, even if it means me becoming a crying mess and no one but the dogs can understand what I'm saying.
I confronted him. I merely stated:
Too late, author. I saw that tweet.
He had no remorse. He replied with this:
Ha!! I stand by it. Idiots!
As you can see, he really did mean that negative reviewers were idiots. Only he didn't appear to have the balls to stand by it really, otherwise why not leave the tweet for all to see and deal with the consequences?
My immediate response to him was this:
Seriously?! An opinion that doesn't sit well with you makes them idiots?!
The author, before replying to me, tweeted again to the general public of Twitter saying:
If you can't think people who hate your book idiots, who can you? Come on, surely you are allowed to know what your own book is about?
Right. Yeah. That got screen capped too. It too disappeared within an hour or two after our conversation.
Then the author came back with this reply to me:
no, saying no book in the world can be as good as Twilight makes them idiots
Now I went through his 1 and 2 star reviews of the book (there are currently 2x 1 star and 8x 2 star reviews) and one person says, 'Books in the vampire genre have a lot to live up to post-Twilight.' If you go to the 3 star reviews, which is a respectable rating in my opinion, you can see one person mention that s/he had seen that it was being said this novel was better than Twilight, but for them, it didn't measure up to Twilight. As for the other 1/2 star reviews, I found them to be eloquent and reasoned their dislike very well.
Apparently preferring Twilight over his book when it comes to vampires makes them idiots.
Personally, I find the Twilight fan base a little intense (some do get a little bit irate when it comes to other vampire novels), and even though I enjoyed the books when I first read them, I can see the flaws of the Twilight saga, and
in my opinion they are not great novels. But if the Twilight series, in another person's
opinion, is better than another vampire novel, does that really make them idiots? And what justifies anyone putting the label 'idiot' on another person?
With that, came my response:
Whilst I see where you are coming from on the Twilight front, it is still an opinion.
And I swiftly got his reply:
Just as it is my opinion that I spy idiocy.
Even reading it again as I write this stuns me.
As you can see, I've kept the author in question somewhat hidden whilst I wrote this post, and if you really wanted know who it was you can find him in my Twitter timeline. I've now decided I'm going to make it all easier for you and let you all know who it is and show you the screen caps of his deleted tweets.
I'm not doing this to be vicious, even though him referring to the negative reviewers as idiots is vicious itself, and I'm even feeling guilty about it. I'm doing this because I think potential reviewers of his book should be made aware of how he feels about you, should you dislike his book- and God help you if you even mention Twilight in the review. However if you do like it, he'll probably retweet you.
The author in question is Matt Haig and his novel is
The Radleys.
Yes, yet another young adult author has spoken out in a public forum before thinking about what they're saying. He did prove one of my theories wrong though; it doesn't matter how many books you've published, even the dab-hands lose their sanity for a second over negative reviews. This is Matt's 8th book, I believe.
Like I said before, I get that moment where you get fed up and have a bitch and a moan, and say things that you don't necessarily mean (although I think Matt did mean this one), but for the love of all things books, do it to your family and friends, who will sympathise with you, not to the people you're going to alienate.
I had Matt's book on my TBR list. I had even left a page open at the weekend with a list of books I was going to order this week and his was on it. Not anymore.
Once again, I must re-iterate, negative reviews don't stop me from buying a book. This behaviour, on the other hand, does.